More Debate on Whether Business Schools Are to Blame

We started to get a little antsy when more than a few days went by since the last “Blame the business schools for the economic meltdown!” article had appeared in the popular press. Thankfully, Forbes provided some salve by asking whether we should blame the business schools, the graduates themselves, or the companies that hire the graduates.

Much of the article is the normal chatter about how the typical business school curriculum places too much emphasis on shareholder value and not enough on improving the community around the enterprise. While we don’t disagree, it’s hard to argue that this trend in management education alone contributed to the problems our economy now faces. It is one ingredient of the problem, for certain, but we’re wary of anyone who believes that the few hundred hours a young professional spends in some some finance courses in business are enough to steer that person towards world-class leadership or financial self-destruction.

We like what Michael Ervolini stated, which nicely sums up a point that we’ve made previously:

B-schools serve a purpose to provide talented employees that have received some minimum training for their career. You can not expect too much from a two-year stint, however, even at the most prestigious of programs. This is particularly the case with an average of only 18 months actually on campus.

While business schools certainly need to take responsibility for the quality of the business leaders they’re putting out in the market, the hiring companies’ jobs have only just begun once they hire these grads. That’s why companies such as General Electric and Procter & Gamble are so successful so consistently — because of the value that they place on training and personal development in their future leaders. This won’t change no matter what new curriculum changes the world’s top business school implement in the coming years.

If you’re just now thinking about getting an MBA, take a look at Veritas Prep’s GMAT prep and MBA admissions consulting offerings. Also, be sure to follow us on Twitter!