Weakening question CR-WB-I question # 18

Neil · **Joined:** Thu Jun 11, 2009 4:18 pm **Posts:** 20

why is D wrong? The question asks
Which of the following....method for achieving a reduction in acid rain?

If the china has no control over the cause of the rain, it's strategy will not help.
doesn't it weaken the arg?

Regards,
Neil

VP_Help · **Joined:** Thu Feb 12, 2009 6:32 pm **Posts:** 497

Choice D is incorrect because it does not address the Chinese government's strategy to reduce acid rain with acting on factors that it can control.

Choice E does this by bringing to light that the strategy won't work because regulations will be ignore.

-- Veritas Help

Neil · **Joined:** Thu Jun 11, 2009 4:18 pm **Posts:** 20

Thanks.
I am still not clear why the strategy should include "factors that it can control"
The question just asks us to prove that the strategy will not work.

Please suggest!

VP_Help · **Joined:** Thu Feb 12, 2009 6:32 pm **Posts:** 497

Think of it this way ... the strategy is about controlling things that China can control: coal-fired power plants, factory emissions, etc. If it does these things it works to some extent even if there are other factors (like volcanos).

Student Testimonials

Weakening question CR-WB-I question # 18

Who is online

VERITAS PREP PRODUCTS & SERVICES Call: 1-800-925-7737 Email: info@veritasprep.com